Transcript
1
00:00:02,030 --> 00:00:38,919.999
If you ache for truth, goodness, and beauty, If you're hungry for a Christianity with substance and strength, if you long for a faith that's big and bold and biblical and all about Jesus Christ, if you're inspired by the idea of one church that has spanned twenty centuries, twenty four time zones, and two hemispheres, enfolding every race, nation, and language, then you're considering Catholicism.
2
00:00:42,93.914656772 --> 00:00:55,363.914656772
So welcome back to a conversation that Corey and I have been having sitting out here in the piney woods on the shore of a great lake at the secret compound on an evening as the sun sets to the west.
3
00:00:56,263.914656772 --> 00:01:02,833.914656772
Over the lake and if that gives any of you like a clue now, we have to move you've given away our location That's right.
4
00:01:02,843.914656772 --> 00:01:09,813.914656772
Like if you want to You want to get on google earth? and do some Figuring out about where we might be.
5
00:01:09,813.914656772 --> 00:01:30,873.908071141
I was actually pretty easy to figure out where we are the hint is That as the sun sets it's setting over this great lake from our perspective So in any case we've been out here this evening and we just finished an interesting conversation, which was the last episode at least I think it was interesting about knowledge and belief and faith and sort of what faith is.
6
00:01:31,183.908071141 --> 00:01:33,912.027308713
This is part of sort of a, little bit of a series we've been doing.
7
00:01:33,952.027308713 --> 00:01:40,362.02730871
Corey and I talked for several episodes about faith and science and the history of Catholicism and scientific.
8
00:01:41,507.02730871 --> 00:01:48,17.02730871
And then Ed and I did several episodes about the Bible, Old Testament, New Testament and the authority of scripture.
9
00:01:48,417.02730871 --> 00:01:55,967.02730871
And so we just kind of thought it'd be interesting to kind of keep this going and talk about faith and what we believe and what we're required to believe and what we know and what we know by faith and so forth.
10
00:01:56,467.02630871 --> 00:02:02,449.8155242
So in the last episode, we were talking about the kind of three things, knowledge.
11
00:02:02,628.40604998 --> 00:02:21,762.61691095
And belief and faith and what those differences are so you can go back and listen to that episode Yeah, but we're going to keep this going and drill down a little bit on faith and the things that we believe by faith and in a sense the things that we are required to believe by faith and catholicism Is a faith it is the catholic faith.
12
00:02:21,772.61691095 --> 00:02:29,89.64352513
It has a substance to it Catholicism is not just showing up to mass and it's not just going through the motions.
13
00:02:29,99.64352513 --> 00:02:34,686.02985203
It is actually believing And having and holding The Catholic faith.
14
00:02:34,726.02985203 --> 00:02:37,396.02985203
There is intellectual and assent involved.
15
00:02:37,626.02985203 --> 00:02:47,901.48796898
There's intellectual assent and then as we look in Hebrews 11, right? That intellectual assent, that certainty and assurance translates into action.
16
00:02:47,961.48796898 --> 00:02:51,1.48696898
And that's the whole point of Hebrews 11 is by faith.
17
00:02:51,200.54100214 --> 00:03:06,73.34238888
People act and so what we want to talk about here in this conversation is what the Catholic faith asks us to believe because I think there's a lot of people listening who go, All right, I'm sort of attracted to some aspects of Catholicism.
18
00:03:06,73.34238888 --> 00:03:07,993.34238888
I find some of this super interesting.
19
00:03:07,993.34338888 --> 00:03:09,143.34238888
I'm considering it.
20
00:03:09,803.34238888 --> 00:03:23,295.99372866
But I want to know what I have to believe and particularly with Catholicism, like, I'm assuming that most of the people who listen to this, if, if they already are maybe a Christian or Protestant or whatever, you know, they believe in God and they believe in Jesus.
21
00:03:23,865.99372866 --> 00:03:38,821.92632904
But what are the peculiarities of Catholicism? And they wonder, do I have to believe in every miracle, any, every Marian apparition, every dogma that's, or doctrine that's handed down by a Pope? And I know.
22
00:03:39,61.92632904 --> 00:03:48,411.92632904
That a lot of my protestant friends, and when I was a protestant, one of my concerns was, if I become catholic, is the pope just gonna make up crazy stuff and I'm required to believe it? Right.
23
00:03:48,411.92632904 --> 00:03:51,651.92632904
Is it shifting sands under my feet? It might, might change tomorrow.
24
00:03:51,681.92632904 --> 00:03:58,531.92632904
Well, were that or is it just crazy stuff like that? Can the pope just make stuff up? And so anyway, we want to get into that.
25
00:03:58,531.92632904 --> 00:04:10,992.074376
What is the substance of the catholic faith? And what are we? Asked to believe, what are we required to believe, what is doctrine and dogma and how is all that defined, right? Yes.
26
00:04:11,172.075376 --> 00:04:16,28.94516238
Now, Corey is going to do some of the heavy lifting here because he's, bright and scholarly and has looked up all this stuff.
27
00:04:16,91.83839337 --> 00:04:31,283.25677568
because, Catholicism, you know, as Chesterton said, one else has spent 2, 000 years thinking about thinking, and it really has a very well developed system, sort epistemology of knowledge, that there are certain sort of categories of belief.
28
00:04:31,513.25677568 --> 00:04:37,623.25677568
There are things that you are required to believe, things that you are recommended to believe, things that, right? Yep.
29
00:04:37,693.25677568 --> 00:04:40,543.25677568
So, Corey is going to break all that down a little bit.
30
00:04:40,573.25677568 --> 00:04:56,233.25677568
So, Corey? If that's who you really are, as we said in the last episode, for all I know, you could be a, an imposter and witness protection, go back and listen to the last episode and I'll explain that, but Corey, if that's your real name, why don't you go ahead and run with this? Okay, I will.
31
00:04:56,533.25677568 --> 00:05:00,758.15677568
Um, so, the easiest way to do this, I think, is going to be to...
32
00:05:00,913.24140921 --> 00:05:33,197.76034015
walk through the different categories first, so that we have language and definitions to use to talk about this, and then we can talk about particulars, because I know any given listener might have a question about a particular type of teaching or document or whatnot, put out by And so the, the way I'm going to approach this is that, if you were going to be invested with the authority to teach the Catholic faith, if you were going to be a bishop or a seminary rector or something like that, you would be required to take an oath.
33
00:05:33,724.15983832 --> 00:05:38,694.15983832
Profession or an affirmation of faith that you're going to be faithful to the teachings of the church.
34
00:05:39,64.15983832 --> 00:05:47,329.45573704
And so that oath, an official oath that is given in those circumstances contains the categories of teachings.
35
00:05:47,709.45573704 --> 00:06:31,697.55521772
That are official and that are the different ways that we understand this and so I'll I'll quote a section And then talk about it a little bit just to elucidate it If you want to chip in Greg you chip in at any time And then once we've been through the categories we can talk about particulars So to begin with that person would would affirm the creed so the the Apostles Creed which walks through the the basics of the faith and then sort of joined to that, um, they would vow with firm faith, I also believe everything contained in the word of God, whether written or handed down in tradition, which the church, either by a solemn judgment or by ordinary and universal magisterium, Sets forth to be believed as divinely revealed.
36
00:06:31,867.55521772 --> 00:06:33,67.55521772
So there's a lot of terms in there.
37
00:06:33,494.5828319 --> 00:06:35,334.5828319
this is the category of dogma.
38
00:06:35,564.5828319 --> 00:06:39,194.5828319
And so this is something that the church has recognized to be divinely revealed.
39
00:06:39,204.5828319 --> 00:06:40,914.5828319
God has said it to be true.
40
00:06:41,414.5828319 --> 00:06:44,42.07953908
And so that can, come from a variety of sources.
41
00:06:44,42.07953908 --> 00:06:45,662.07953908
That can be directly from scripture.
42
00:06:46,72.07953908 --> 00:06:49,912.07953908
That can be something that the Pope has dogmatically defined.
43
00:06:50,312.07953908 --> 00:06:54,662.07953908
Um, that can be something that an ecumenical council has dogmatically defined or something.
44
00:06:54,962.07953908 --> 00:07:01,992.07953908
The phrase ordinary and universal magisterium essentially means this is what the church always and everywhere has believed together.
45
00:07:02,623.01233467 --> 00:07:02,833.01233467
Okay.
46
00:07:02,833.01233467 --> 00:07:03,143.01233467
Okay.
47
00:07:03,143.01333467 --> 00:07:03,623.01333467
Just want to.
48
00:07:03,683.01333467 --> 00:07:03,923.01333467
Yeah.
49
00:07:03,943.01333467 --> 00:07:04,203.01333467
Go ahead.
50
00:07:04,563.01333467 --> 00:07:05,493.01333467
Point of clarification.
51
00:07:05,503.01333467 --> 00:07:05,723.01333467
Yep.
52
00:07:05,763.01333467 --> 00:07:06,93.01333467
Okay.
53
00:07:06,412.38102344 --> 00:07:09,922.38202344
you explained it well, but you went kind of quick there and I want to just slow down a little bit.
54
00:07:09,962.38202344 --> 00:07:10,142.38202344
Yep.
55
00:07:10,202.38202344 --> 00:07:11,362.38202344
For anybody who's listening.
56
00:07:12,282.38202344 --> 00:07:13,142.38202344
Dogma.
57
00:07:13,262.38202344 --> 00:07:18,542.38202344
Cause I know you're going to introduce a distinction here between dogma and doctrines, right? Yep.
58
00:07:18,582.38202344 --> 00:07:18,602.38202344
Yeah.
59
00:07:18,907.38202344 --> 00:07:24,907.38202344
And so, just to clarify that, dogma is something that we are required to believe.
60
00:07:25,17.38202344 --> 00:07:27,487.38202344
We're required? You can, you cannot say...
61
00:07:28,377.38202344 --> 00:07:35,417.38202344
That you hold the Catholic faith, unless you hold this by faith, unless you believe this.
62
00:07:35,457.38202344 --> 00:07:35,677.38202344
Right.
63
00:07:35,677.38202344 --> 00:07:37,347.38202344
So this is the category of dogma.
64
00:07:37,659.09617722 --> 00:07:48,389.09617722
it is part of the definition of being a Catholic to hold this belief because the church has defined it to be divinely revealed, that God has told us that this is true.
65
00:07:48,439.09617722 --> 00:07:52,759.09617722
And again, just to be clear, I know you're making this clear, but I want to make it uber clear.
66
00:07:52,769.09617722 --> 00:07:53,29.09617722
Yep.
67
00:07:53,189.09617722 --> 00:07:54,129.09617722
Clarity is a good thing.
68
00:07:54,904.09617722 --> 00:08:03,354.09517722
So we're going to get into, as we move down this hierarchy of knowledge, right, things that you're recommended to believe in, you're going to get to that, right? Yep, we'll get there.
69
00:08:03,434.09617722 --> 00:08:11,484.09617722
Uh, you know, the belief that the Shroud of Turin is real, you can believe it or not believe it, or that, you know, the Virgin Mary appeared at, We'll get there.
70
00:08:11,494.09617722 --> 00:08:12,404.09617722
Lords, we'll get there.
71
00:08:12,444.09617722 --> 00:08:12,604.09617722
Yeah.
72
00:08:12,624.09617722 --> 00:08:21,684.09517722
But, but I just want to say for those who are listening, not everything in the Catholic faith is required, but there are things that you cannot say.
73
00:08:21,684.09617722 --> 00:08:32,914.09617722
And I say this not only to non Catholics considering Catholicism, but I say to those of you who are Catholics who, you know, you know who you are, who are maybe a little loosey goosey.
74
00:08:33,804.09617722 --> 00:08:57,206.27283836
And I think one of the things that We struggle with today is a lot of syncretism, in the postmodern church, individualism, individualism, syncretism, where we, we sort of say, Hey, you know, I've got what I really believe is some kind of weirdo combination of Catholicism and Buddhism and UFO ology and, you know, and stuff that I got off Star Trek and, you know, Star Wars or whatever.
75
00:08:57,206.27283836 --> 00:09:00,916.27283836
And it's all sort of, you know, kind of become this goulash in my mind.
76
00:09:01,836.27283836 --> 00:09:06,431.27283836
And that's, You can't do that, at least with respect to these things that are dogmatic.
77
00:09:06,451.27283836 --> 00:09:11,651.27183836
You have to hold these or you are not holding the Catholic faith.
78
00:09:11,671.27283836 --> 00:09:15,771.27283836
And in some sense, Corey, is your salvation in danger? Well, you're in error.
79
00:09:16,0.74571549 --> 00:09:20,884.85797373
and that is a problem that can, error in belief can lead to error in action.
80
00:09:21,340.16704371 --> 00:09:28,170.16804371
and so simply being mistaken about something doesn't necessarily mean that you have lost your salvation, but it is, it is risky business.
81
00:09:28,200.16804371 --> 00:09:32,20.16804371
And you, if you are corrected and you do not.
82
00:09:32,300.16804371 --> 00:09:33,510.16804371
Heed the correction.
83
00:09:34,30.16804371 --> 00:09:36,720.16804371
Then that's the category of heresy that we talked about.
84
00:09:36,720.16804371 --> 00:09:36,840.16804371
Yeah.
85
00:09:37,890.16804371 --> 00:09:43,210.16804371
A few episodes we talked about heresy, but, you know, going back to our last episode about knowledge and belief and all these kinds of things.
86
00:09:43,544.53014685 --> 00:09:46,294.53014685
it's one thing to say, well, I was mistaken.
87
00:09:46,944.53014685 --> 00:09:58,794.53014685
Like just because maybe my Sunday school teachers didn't make it clear, somebody I, you know, was not paying attention in class, you know, in confirmation class.
88
00:09:58,794.53014685 --> 00:10:14,938.43413304
And I just, you know, I, I, I can be mistaken, but if you deliberately choose to believe something contrary to dogma, right? Because you don't want to believe it, then you need to go to confession and you need to change.
89
00:10:15,388.43413304 --> 00:10:17,208.43313304
You need to change, right? But it is a sin.
90
00:10:17,218.43413304 --> 00:10:18,178.43413304
It's a mortal sin.
91
00:10:18,808.43413304 --> 00:10:19,368.43413304
You know, okay.
92
00:10:19,468.43413304 --> 00:10:19,768.43413304
Right.
93
00:10:19,808.43413304 --> 00:10:31,413.43413304
I mean, in, in, in Catholicism, you go, if I have chosen to deliberately believe something Contrary to the dogma of the church, I am in mortal sin, if that's a deliberate choice, not just an error, you know, I'm mistaken.
94
00:10:31,423.43413304 --> 00:10:32,333.43413304
That's the vital distinction.
95
00:10:32,343.43413304 --> 00:10:45,699.97509254
Then I need to go to confession and confess my error, and if you are a Catholic and you're listening and you have chosen to willfully, contradict the dogma of the church or believe something contrary to the dogma.
96
00:10:46,43.39681446 --> 00:10:55,521.82731723
you are immortal sin and you are an heir and you need to seek confession and, and, and of course that implies that you, amend your ways.
97
00:10:55,921.82731723 --> 00:11:03,67.56157601
Now I, I say all that because I want to emphasize, as Corey is, the seriousness of these dogmas, these dogmatic teachings.
98
00:11:03,67.56157601 --> 00:11:03,237.56157601
Right.
99
00:11:03,277.56157601 --> 00:11:03,677.56157601
Okay, go ahead.
100
00:11:03,757.56157601 --> 00:11:04,47.56157601
Okay.
101
00:11:04,507.7150134 --> 00:11:07,227.7150134
so that's sort of at the high end, the very high end.
102
00:11:07,247.7150134 --> 00:11:10,910.98988357
And then in this oath, we get to the next part, in which you would vow.
103
00:11:11,270.98888357 --> 00:11:19,10.98888357
I also firmly accept and hold each and everything definitely proposed by the church regarding teaching on faith and morals.
104
00:11:19,700.98888357 --> 00:11:23,810.98988357
And so to, to parse that a little bit, so this is also infallible teaching.
105
00:11:24,50.98988357 --> 00:11:32,907.39057694
This, this is held by the church to be true, without error, but it's not something that we know that God has directly revealed to us.
106
00:11:32,907.39057694 --> 00:11:40,56.60682832
This isn't like the level of dogma of, you know, God has revealed that Christ is God, holy God and holy man.
107
00:11:40,66.60482832 --> 00:11:42,286.60582832
Give us, give us two practical examples.
108
00:11:42,616.60582832 --> 00:11:45,486.60482832
Give us a practical example of a dogma.
109
00:11:45,946.60582832 --> 00:11:49,814.4138007
And contrast that with a practical example of, a doctrine that you're talking about.
110
00:11:49,894.4138007 --> 00:11:55,315.03094067
Okay, so like what I was just saying, it's dogma that Christ is fully God and fully man.
111
00:11:55,535.03194067 --> 00:11:57,375.03094067
That Jesus died and rose again.
112
00:11:57,375.03094067 --> 00:11:59,5.03094067
Jesus died on a cross and rose again.
113
00:11:59,5.03094067 --> 00:12:00,125.03094067
He was bodily resurrected.
114
00:12:00,135.03194067 --> 00:12:02,825.03194067
That, that God is Trinity, three in one.
115
00:12:03,195.03194067 --> 00:12:08,825.03194067
Those, those are examples of dogs, basically the Nicene Creed or the Apostle Nicene Creed and, and some other things.
116
00:12:08,825.03194067 --> 00:12:11,385.03194067
We can talk more about specific examples.
117
00:12:11,705.03194067 --> 00:12:14,785.03094067
I believe in God, the father almighty maker of heaven and earth and Jesus Christ is only son.
118
00:12:14,785.03194067 --> 00:12:14,895.03194067
Right.
119
00:12:15,255.03194067 --> 00:12:19,615.03094067
And there are things that have been defined by councils and popes to be God has revealed this.
120
00:12:19,625.03194067 --> 00:12:19,815.03194067
Okay.
121
00:12:20,155.03094067 --> 00:12:23,85.03194067
Um, and then there are things, the canon of scripture.
122
00:12:23,440.03194067 --> 00:12:26,590.03194067
Dogmatic, that would fit in this category.
123
00:12:26,600.03194067 --> 00:12:31,837.82674179
So that, that is something that is free to, disbelieve in the canon of scripture.
124
00:12:32,67.82674179 --> 00:12:33,547.82674179
You are not free to disbelieve in it.
125
00:12:33,567.82674179 --> 00:12:36,377.82574179
It is infallibly defined, but it's not at the level of dogma.
126
00:12:36,387.82674179 --> 00:12:38,457.82674179
So it's at this, this second level.
127
00:12:38,457.82674179 --> 00:12:44,337.82674179
So these are things that are essentially derived or deduced by the church authoritatively from dogma.
128
00:12:44,337.82674179 --> 00:12:48,627.82674179
So given dogma, then the implications of dogma are doctrine.
129
00:12:48,777.82674179 --> 00:12:51,487.82674179
And so a lot of moral teaching would fall in this category.
130
00:12:51,717.82674179 --> 00:12:52,407.82674179
Give us an example.
131
00:12:53,29.22523995 --> 00:12:57,779.22423995
the, sort of the classic example from the last couple of generations is contraception.
132
00:12:57,916.71316629 --> 00:13:03,978.73419484
Pope Paul VI, Saint Paul VI, teaching on the immorality of artificial contraception.
133
00:13:04,338.73419484 --> 00:13:06,28.73419484
It was based on tradition.
134
00:13:06,68.73419484 --> 00:13:09,708.73419484
It was based on the natural law and the law of the church on scripture.
135
00:13:09,965.13488822 --> 00:13:12,455.13488822
and so it was in that sense deduced.
136
00:13:12,495.13488822 --> 00:13:22,785.13488822
It's not as if God directly told us at the level of dogma, contraception is wrong, but the church has defined this in a way that is not disputable for the Catholic.
137
00:13:22,795.13488822 --> 00:13:23,75.13488822
Okay.
138
00:13:23,105.13488822 --> 00:13:31,136.37894899
Since we're sitting out here in the forest and the sun is setting and there's nobody, you know, within a long way around us other than Sasquatch.
139
00:13:31,941.37994899 --> 00:13:50,108.39339192
And I have an adult beverage and an In Vino Veritas, I'm going to say to you, then, is it licit for a Catholic to be pro abortion? No, that would be an example of this category, that it's a, it's an infallible moral teaching of the church based on divine revelation.
140
00:13:50,128.39439192 --> 00:13:53,68.39339192
So, think divine revelation, thou shalt not kill.
141
00:13:53,427.91551807 --> 00:14:06,234.31282102
there, there are specific things in the Bible and in apostolic tradition that prohibit, Moral actions, like abortion, and then the church has reasoned from those things to have that progression.
142
00:14:06,234.31282102 --> 00:14:07,374.31282102
Let's do lightning round here.
143
00:14:07,994.31282102 --> 00:14:08,894.31282102
Okay? Okay.
144
00:14:08,934.31182102 --> 00:14:18,154.31282102
So if I, if I say, all right, let's talk about contemporary Catholics, whether they are individuals or people in positions of influence, like politicians.
145
00:14:18,814.31282102 --> 00:14:22,694.31282102
Uh, someone who says, I'm a faithful Catholic, but I just believe in abortion.
146
00:14:23,149.31282102 --> 00:14:23,459.31282102
Illicit.
147
00:14:23,499.31282102 --> 00:14:23,939.31282102
Illicit.
148
00:14:24,179.31282102 --> 00:14:24,649.31282102
Illicit.
149
00:14:25,209.31282102 --> 00:14:29,9.31282102
I am a faithful catholic, but I believe in same sex marriage.
150
00:14:29,119.31282102 --> 00:14:29,599.31282102
Illicit.
151
00:14:30,78.80618211 --> 00:14:34,742.63784758
I am a Catholic but I don't believe in the real presence in the Eucharist.
152
00:14:34,853.11656064 --> 00:14:37,679.34868423
I think that it's just a symbol that would be illicit.
153
00:14:38,89.34768423 --> 00:15:01,314.43280806
Okay, not not valid Yeah, that would violate this category of infallible teaching that one arguably could be called dog mind I'm not 100% sure about that one because it's scriptural but so dogma You're in mortal sin if you deliberately disbelieve in it, and doctrine are those things that dogma, and therefore carry a sort of weight.
154
00:15:01,594.43280806 --> 00:15:20,712.92125215
So if I, for example, if I believe something willfully against dogma, but I am an error, I'm not, it's not illicit if I act on that, right? So I'm not a confessor, so I'm certainly open to the correction of, priests and moral theologians.
155
00:15:20,713.02125215 --> 00:15:22,22.92225215
Yeah, I'm curious about that.
156
00:15:22,32.92225215 --> 00:15:29,542.92325215
Um, but what, what I understand from these categories is that both dogma and doctrine here are infallible teachings.
157
00:15:29,998.37055498 --> 00:15:37,89.04726427
what I would say to our listener, neither, obviously, Corey, I mean, I've been a, I was a Protestant pastor, but I've obviously never been a Catholic confessor.
158
00:15:37,579.04726427 --> 00:15:52,712.98211698
But I would just say as a, brotherly suggestion that if I found myself really doubting the doctrines of the church and I found myself tempted or finding myself falling into believing in things that are not licit, I certainly would go to confession.
159
00:15:52,812.98211698 --> 00:15:56,782.98211698
Well, if I was, if I was tempted to, or I was doubting.
160
00:15:56,992.98211698 --> 00:16:05,77.69511704
Probably what I would first do is I would talk to my priest or talk to a, a faithful Catholic who I feel could, you know, talk me through this.
161
00:16:05,77.69511704 --> 00:16:11,637.69411704
Because if you're at the level of doubts and temptations, then you may not have committed the sin.
162
00:16:12,847.69411704 --> 00:16:15,267.69411704
If you figure out that you have, then I would go to confession.
163
00:16:15,683.00921269 --> 00:16:19,333.00921269
but if, if you're in the position where you have definitely.
164
00:16:19,442.49947969 --> 00:16:25,62.49947969
decided that you oppose the teachings of the church and that's not just you've acted on it.
165
00:16:25,62.49947969 --> 00:16:31,632.49947969
So, in other words, not just you've had an abortion or you've practiced contraception, but that you basically have decided that you disagree with the church.
166
00:16:31,992.49947969 --> 00:16:36,892.49847969
I would recommend going to confession and hearing what your confessor has to say.
167
00:16:36,942.49947969 --> 00:16:38,157.39947969
The thing about it, too, is that.
168
00:16:38,567.49947969 --> 00:16:42,367.4994797
In order for him to validly absolve you, you would have to actually be contrite.
169
00:16:42,367.4994797 --> 00:16:47,47.4984797
So you would have to be confessing a sin, not going into confession to say, Ha ha, I believe.
170
00:16:47,57.4994797 --> 00:16:52,417.4994797
But I would be concerned about myself and I would go in there and say, Hey look, I'm really struggling.
171
00:16:52,417.4994797 --> 00:16:55,177.4994797
So if you're concerned about it, then that means that...
172
00:16:55,642.4994797 --> 00:17:04,162.4994797
Either you're the Holy Spirit is working in your heart and leading you away from sin, or you're, you're contrite for something, some sin that you have committed.
173
00:17:04,422.4994797 --> 00:17:07,762.4994797
And so if you're, if you're worried about it and you're feeling bad about it, that's a good sign.
174
00:17:08,40.1010373 --> 00:17:11,947.9702048
get thee to a confessional and listen to what your confessor says.
175
00:17:11,947.9702048 --> 00:17:12,857.9682048
Right, exactly.
176
00:17:13,261.451918 --> 00:17:17,271.451918
so to sum up those, those two top tier categories are both infallible.
177
00:17:17,391.452918 --> 00:17:20,43.5302925
The church teaches them, as without error.
178
00:17:20,43.5302925 --> 00:17:21,423.5302925
The first is dogma.
179
00:17:21,813.5302925 --> 00:17:24,733.5302925
That stuff God has told us, so we know it's true.
180
00:17:25,163.5302925 --> 00:17:27,653.5302925
The second level, we can use the word doctrine for that.
181
00:17:27,683.5302925 --> 00:17:33,833.5302925
It's teachings of the church that have been derived from dogma that are still considered infallible.
182
00:17:33,873.5292925 --> 00:17:35,423.5302925
No, I keep interrupting your narrative here.
183
00:17:35,423.5302925 --> 00:17:36,53.5302925
No, go ahead.
184
00:17:36,183.5302925 --> 00:17:49,317.5807668
But, I know there's gonna be people out there who are gonna say, Well, how am I supposed to understand Catholics who are in positions of influence or in positions of ecclesial office? Mm-hmm.
185
00:17:49,887.5807668 --> 00:17:56,767.5807668
who run around, whether they're a ca, a professor at a Catholic university, or they're a priest, right.
186
00:17:57,847.5807668 --> 00:18:02,357.5807668
Or even a bishop who makes public statements.
187
00:18:03,42.5807668 --> 00:18:06,442.5807668
And teaches things that seem contrary to the doctrines of the church.
188
00:18:06,492.5807668 --> 00:18:12,522.5797668
Aren't they, are they licit or illicit? Because, like, I'm just, let's put our cards on the table.
189
00:18:12,832.5807668 --> 00:18:28,654.7709262
You can go on the, on Google, and in five seconds, find priests, professors, even some bishops, who say things that sound like they're pro abortion, pro gay marriage, you know, all the things that you mentioned.
190
00:18:29,364.7709262 --> 00:18:38,904.7709262
And so it is causing a lot of confusion and concern, not only among the faithful, but among.
191
00:18:39,794.7709262 --> 00:18:46,34.7709262
Those who are considering joining the Catholic Church and going, wait a minute, you guys can't even, your own house isn't even in order.
192
00:18:46,332.452233 --> 00:18:49,300.578006
so what, what's real and what's not real? Let's say you.
193
00:18:49,350.579006 --> 00:18:51,980.578006
Yeah, I mean, you bring up a real problem.
194
00:18:52,51.384249 --> 00:19:00,586.384249
and to one degree or another, it's always been a problem because Human beings are sinful and they, they have errors or they mess up or they do bad things.
195
00:19:00,926.384249 --> 00:19:11,808.5744085
And so yes, you're going to find people in positions of authority in the church who are going to be speaking against the truths of the faith, whether they're dogmatic truths or doctrinal truths, infallible truths of the faith.
196
00:19:12,274.4467551 --> 00:19:19,484.4457551
and that does not change the truth just because someone is speaking in error doesn't mean either that the truth is uncertain or that.
197
00:19:19,739.4467551 --> 00:19:28,251.5726476
What the church was teaching as true has changed or was false the whole time, and that doesn't change the fact that it's a grave scandal.
198
00:19:28,331.5716476 --> 00:19:30,986.865321
Like you say, it, it fills people's minds with doubts.
199
00:19:30,986.865321 --> 00:19:32,856.864321
It, it scares them off of the church.
200
00:19:32,856.864321 --> 00:19:35,316.865321
It, it causes all kinds of problems.
201
00:19:35,536.4188549 --> 00:19:43,366.3198549
so I'm not excusing it in that sense, but it also doesn't change a person in authority spouting off it.
202
00:19:43,646.4198549 --> 00:20:06,330.3061896
Against the truths of the faith doesn't change the truths of the faith and I would say to any listener out there who's concerned about that and I'm not going to name names, but you can go on Google and find some prominent Catholic professors, priests and bishops who seem to be saying things that are not licit and like, look, I'm just going to say this.
203
00:20:07,930.3061896 --> 00:20:10,160.3061896
You don't know how this story ends.
204
00:20:11,200.3061896 --> 00:20:24,549.0658272
I can go back to scripture and I can see examples not only in the New Testament but the Old Testament of unfaithful priests and that over time God dealt with them.
205
00:20:25,319.0910862 --> 00:20:29,779.0910862
You know, and I'm not, you know, saying that some, right, it's not, it's not up to me.
206
00:20:29,779.0910862 --> 00:20:30,179.0910862
I'm not.
207
00:20:30,419.0910862 --> 00:20:30,749.0910862
Right.
208
00:20:30,969.0910862 --> 00:20:33,759.0900862
But, you know, you don't know how this is going to turn out.
209
00:20:34,39.0910862 --> 00:20:42,664.2271301
I think, you know, the one that comes to my mind is the sons of Samuel, right in the old Testament, the priest Samuel, the one who anointed David, Yeah.
210
00:20:42,664.2281301 --> 00:20:44,484.2281301
Your sons do not follow in your ways.
211
00:20:44,484.2281301 --> 00:20:44,834.2281301
Yeah.
212
00:20:44,834.2281301 --> 00:20:46,954.2281301
And his, his sons were corrupt.
213
00:20:47,724.2281301 --> 00:20:56,944.2766481
And they were taking the tithes and offerings and they were doing all kinds of other sort of corrupt things and, it was a scandal for a long time and in the end it, God dealt with it.
214
00:20:57,374.2766481 --> 00:21:01,4.2756481
So, you know, for those of you who feel like you turn...
215
00:21:01,494.2766481 --> 00:21:37,564.3065805
On the internet and you scroll through the news and you go Father so and so or bishop so and so or professor so and so is saying these crazy things and it really distresses me what's happened to the church Aren't we supposed to be faithful to the truth and to the dogmas and the doctrines? Yep Yeah, but and and but be patient because you don't know how this turns out and the wheel of history grinds slowly And I think you bringing up this issue both helps to clarify something about these first two categories and also as a good segue to the next thing we're going to talk about the next set of things we'll talk about in terms of clarifying what we've already talked about.
216
00:21:37,824.7791424 --> 00:21:46,124.0438396
this speaks to the source of Dogmas or of infallible doctrines, dogmas, as we said, are something that's divinely revealed.
217
00:21:46,398.2414332 --> 00:21:48,898.2404332
doctrines are derived from those divinely revealed things.
218
00:21:48,898.2414332 --> 00:22:00,289.0038317
And so the obvious question there is who decided that this was divinely revealed, or that it follows, reasonably from divine revelation and what it says in this oath and what is true is that it's, it's the church.
219
00:22:00,644.0038317 --> 00:22:24,564.6134374
Big C in the sense of this is something that's been defined, by the universal creeds of the church or by an ecumenical council or by the Pope teaching, with his full authority, not just any old thing he says, which we'll get to, because that gets to our, one of our other categories, but this isn't just Father Father Jim, who said something once, or even Bishop Jim.
220
00:22:24,684.6134374 --> 00:22:39,644.6134374
Just because Professor Peabody at Georgetown University published a scandalous article, or just because Father Martinez runs around saying things that seem to contradict the doctrines of the church, or just because Bishop Butterpants Published an article.
221
00:22:39,654.6134374 --> 00:22:40,884.6134374
These names are getting weirder and weirder.
222
00:22:40,884.6134374 --> 00:22:41,134.6134374
Yeah.
223
00:22:42,174.6134374 --> 00:23:07,809.5762662
Well as the sun sets and and I enjoy my hot toddy here i'm, i'm getting a little more creative but uh, look But I would introduce another d You talked about doctrine and dogma and doctrine and there's another d that's at play here and that's discipline And the the discipline of god of the discipline of the church sometimes grinds slowly if you look at church history look at the Aryan heresy, of the 4th century.
224
00:23:07,809.5762662 --> 00:23:12,629.5762662
It took a hundred years, a hundred and fifty years for that to be, work itself out.
225
00:23:13,149.5762662 --> 00:23:19,599.5762662
History grinds slowly, and the Catholic Church is 2, 000 years old, and things are not always going to be resolved.
226
00:23:19,856.3638041 --> 00:23:23,238.4197564
In, five years or ten years or a hundred years.
227
00:23:23,488.4197564 --> 00:23:25,78.4197564
Okay, so I've interrupted you enough.
228
00:23:25,328.4197564 --> 00:23:27,328.4197564
Dogma, doctrine, go.
229
00:23:27,428.4187564 --> 00:23:34,565.8326488
Okay, and so the third part of this oath, I'm glad you brought up the word discipline, because I think that's, that's a good, word to have in mind when we get to this third part.
230
00:23:35,105.8112265 --> 00:23:46,740.8112265
so it says, Moreover, I adhere with religious submission of will and intellect to the teachings which either the Roman pontiff, so that's a pope, Or the College of Bishops enunciate when they exercise their authentic magisterium.
231
00:23:46,760.8112265 --> 00:23:52,820.8112265
So that's them teaching officially, even if they do not intend to proclaim these teachings by a definite act.
232
00:23:53,210.8102265 --> 00:24:01,240.8102265
So this is something that a legitimate authority in the church, so the Pope or the College of Bishops, is asserting not definitively.
233
00:24:01,490.8112265 --> 00:24:06,751.5950473
So this could be a disciplinary measure, or, as, as you mentioned that word.
234
00:24:06,751.5950473 --> 00:24:10,141.5940473
So this is, we think that this position over here.
235
00:24:10,456.5950473 --> 00:24:33,645.2857447
Seem shady don't entertain that Or it could be this is a this is a theological idea that is not divine revelation or hasn't been defined by the church But this is my opinion as your bishop or as your Pope and I teach this And it's not contrary to the dogma or doctrine and I'm teaching this And so, the, phrase used here is, religious submission of will and intellect.
236
00:24:33,655.2857447 --> 00:24:35,735.2857447
So this is, this is a matter of authority.
237
00:24:35,735.2857447 --> 00:24:46,340.0891073
This is, I'm submitting myself to the authority if they're teaching something that, that's reasonably under the, umbrella of Catholic teaching, but isn't asserted to be definite.
238
00:24:47,207.4144739 --> 00:24:59,168.709299
And see, this is where I think the rubber meets the road, and the difference with Protestantism, because in a sort of Protestant, sort of theological worldview, I am the ultimate Arbiter.
239
00:25:00,8.709299 --> 00:25:00,158.709299
Yeah.
240
00:25:00,188.709299 --> 00:25:05,508.709299
I had somebody writing, a couple of people write emails and say that, um, they don't like my pronunciations of words.
241
00:25:05,948.709299 --> 00:25:14,118.709299
And my, what I fall back on is that I grew up in the, uh, surfer beach communities of Southern California.
242
00:25:14,118.709299 --> 00:25:21,98.709299
And so, My Southern California drawl, which has been conditioned by moving and traveling all around the world.
243
00:25:21,448.709299 --> 00:25:24,78.708299
Uh, I don't know, I don't know, whatever.
244
00:25:24,118.709299 --> 00:25:28,108.709299
Arbiter, arbitire, tomato, tomato, whatever.
245
00:25:28,348.708299 --> 00:25:31,918.709299
Right, so, so like, I'm the ultimate judge.
246
00:25:32,548.708299 --> 00:25:35,968.708299
Right, because the notion that I can read scripture.
247
00:25:36,528.709299 --> 00:26:07,360.0085262
And decide for myself, right? So so the priesthood of all believers the purpose skewity of scripture all these things that protestantism and calvinism teaches Says I can look at scripture and come to my own decisions And I don't have to submit to authority and you know, you're the chesterton, walking Encyclopedia this quote machine on this but doesn't chesterton have a quote about uh, the the thing about catholicism is acknowledging That there's People who are smarter than you.
248
00:26:07,390.0085262 --> 00:26:07,730.0085262
Sure.
249
00:26:07,790.0085262 --> 00:26:08,130.0085262
Sure.
250
00:26:08,200.0085262 --> 00:26:12,270.0085262
Right? I mean at the end of the day, right? Like I want to believe that I can read my Bible.
251
00:26:12,270.0085262 --> 00:26:13,170.0085262
I can flip it open.
252
00:26:13,170.0085262 --> 00:26:40,900.0085262
I can decide what's right and what's wrong Right, but there's no controlling authority in Protestantism I was talking to somebody about that the other day if you look at classical Protestantism you and I were talking about this Yeah, if you look at classical like confessional Protestantism like in the first hundred years after the Reformation you had these synods like Um, the Westminster Confession or the Augsburg Confession or the Heidelberg Confession, but that kind of thing hasn't happened in 500 years.
253
00:26:41,150.0085262 --> 00:26:54,370.0085262
There is no legitimate confessional authority because any denomination in the United States or Europe right now, and I mean, just go on the news or if you're a part of one, as soon as you come to serious disagreement, the denomination just divides.
254
00:26:54,510.0085262 --> 00:27:06,135.0085262
Nobody has authority in the, you and I have talked about this a lot, that people will write in and say, What is the Protestant position on X? And you go, there is no such thing as a Protestant position because nobody has authority.
255
00:27:06,405.0085262 --> 00:27:21,215.0085262
And I think this is really, really super important about if you're considering Catholicism, it is the humility and the willingness to, what's the phrase? Submit religious submission of will and intellect, religious submission of will and intellect.
256
00:27:21,235.0085262 --> 00:27:44,148.4940761
And, you know, as somebody who spent, you know, my life as an evangelical, Protestant or Calvinist Protestant to say, I am going to acknowledge that there are authorities that I have to religiously submit to, my will and intellect to, even if I don't completely understand or maybe don't even completely agree, I acknowledge that there's legitimate authority.
257
00:27:44,198.4940761 --> 00:27:44,418.4940761
Right.
258
00:27:44,568.4950761 --> 00:27:50,528.4950761
And this, and in this category, this isn't something that is being asserted to be definitive or divinely, divinely revealed.
259
00:27:50,528.4950761 --> 00:27:54,649.166112
So this will, this category would often, touch on disputed.
260
00:27:55,294.228612 --> 00:28:05,994.227612
Okay, so let me throw, let me throw one out that I think is disputed in the Catholic Church and about which there are disputes and it's something that I had to wrestle with, okay? And that's, um, the Catholic position on the death penalty.
261
00:28:06,54.228612 --> 00:28:07,244.228612
I was gonna bring that one up.
262
00:28:07,274.228612 --> 00:28:16,415.3226917
Okay, so here's the deal about the death penalty, right? um, there are still some Catholics who argue because in Catholic tradition there is, or just war theory.
263
00:28:16,585.3226917 --> 00:28:17,925.3226917
Yeah, which are related.
264
00:28:18,75.3226917 --> 00:28:18,885.3226917
Which are related.
265
00:28:19,195.3236917 --> 00:28:48,869.7682774
In which, uh, you can go back to the great Catholic thinkers and doctors of the church, and Thomas Aquinas will defend these things, and then people will say, well, yeah, but the Catholic, and I think one of the things for me about when I entered the Catholic Church, I had several people in my life, right, who said, well, wait a minute, doesn't Catholicism require you to, you know, kind of let go of the death penalty? And I said, well, I don't know for sure if it does, but it seems to, and last few popes have certainly seemed to say that.
266
00:28:48,899.7682774 --> 00:28:54,249.7672774
And I said, you know, it seems to me part of the religious submission of my will.
267
00:28:54,327.0712217 --> 00:28:57,507.0283771
an intellect to say, you know, I gotta let this one go.
268
00:28:58,454.2642178 --> 00:29:40,132.6269073
when I am inclined to say I think maybe the death penalty or just war in certain instances are legitimate I think at a certain point I I had to say, you know What to become catholic is to be humble enough to say I maybe not only do I not have all the answers but sometimes Maybe the answers that I think I have I have to be willing to submit to a higher authority Yeah and that doesn't mean that there can't still be debate and dispute about these kinds of things It does it just means that I'm not allowed to you know Blow up the conversation and leave the table flip the table over there and these issues are not dogma So so I think this is where Protestants get confused.
269
00:29:40,442.6269073 --> 00:29:45,332.6279073
So the Catholic position on the death penalty or whatever Is not dogmatic.
270
00:29:45,762.6279073 --> 00:29:51,2.6279073
That's not part of that level of dogma that is required to not asserted it infallibly.
271
00:29:51,12.6279073 --> 00:29:56,392.6279073
The church is reasoning with scripture and with the deposit of the faith, but it has not made a definition on this.
272
00:29:56,402.6279073 --> 00:30:12,472.6279073
If you think about this like a series of dominoes or implications, like you can say, okay, here's the first thing that pushes the first domino, right? And that's, those, those are those dogmatic truths, right? Jesus was the son of God, the second person of the Trinity, died on the cross, rose on the third day.
273
00:30:13,24.1470309 --> 00:30:14,114.1470309
That's the first thing.
274
00:30:14,314.1470309 --> 00:30:31,595.9549911
Then there is a series of dominoes that if that is true, if then, if then, if then, and when you get to things like the death penalty or whatever you're three or two or three or four or five or however many degrees removed from that.
275
00:30:31,895.9549911 --> 00:30:51,877.0110629
So in a sense, I'm called to submit maybe to my To my bishop, and not contradict the bishop of the diocese of which I am a member but i'm not required to believe it in the same way That I believe that jesus rose on Easter Sun.
276
00:30:52,77.0110629 --> 00:30:52,337.0110629
Right.
277
00:30:52,527.0110629 --> 00:30:56,158.063298
And the phrase here is adherence with, submission of will.
278
00:30:56,448.063298 --> 00:30:58,308.063298
And so that's not the same as assent.
279
00:30:59,318.063298 --> 00:30:59,648.063298
Right.
280
00:31:00,18.063298 --> 00:31:00,308.063298
Right.
281
00:31:00,548.063298 --> 00:31:05,138.063298
I made, I may humbly disagree, but I also humbly obey.
282
00:31:06,128.063298 --> 00:31:35,378.136075
And you know, I think this is really the hard thing I think for a lot of people about coming into Catholicism and it, frankly, it's hard for a lot of Catholics who are maybe not, maybe living their Catholic faith, who say, I just My positions, and if you look at things like contraception, I saw a statistic today on the internet that 89% of practicing Catholics, in the American church disagree with the church's position on contraception.
283
00:31:35,538.135075 --> 00:31:36,178.136075
I knew it was high.
284
00:31:36,188.135075 --> 00:31:37,168.136075
I didn't realize that high.
285
00:31:37,567.6906089 --> 00:31:42,157.6906089
you know, and I don't know statistics or stats or stats or stats, right? But it's, it's right.
286
00:31:42,187.6906089 --> 00:31:46,626.7354098
It's something crazy like that and so again, that's not the same as believing Jesus.
287
00:31:47,86.7354098 --> 00:31:54,40.7773739
Rose on Easter Sunday morning, but it is a, an act of submission to the authority of the church.
288
00:31:54,100.7773739 --> 00:31:59,350.7773739
Well, and, and just to be clear, cause we talked about that issue at the level of doctrine.
289
00:31:59,350.7773739 --> 00:32:05,896.9385572
So that, uh, contraception is not in this third category where there's legitimate dispute, but you should submit.
290
00:32:05,996.9385572 --> 00:32:06,546.9385572
Correct.
291
00:32:06,696.9395572 --> 00:32:08,916.9395572
But that's in the previous category.
292
00:32:08,926.9395572 --> 00:32:14,736.9395572
So going down those domino chain, but there are things where I go, you know, even if I'm struggling with it.
293
00:32:15,216.9395572 --> 00:32:27,114.7764935
There is a component of Catholicism that is basically understanding that I, there's apostolic authority, the church, and I, and what was the phrase? Religious submission of will and intellect.
294
00:32:27,494.7764935 --> 00:32:29,344.7764935
Okay, I've interrupted you enough, keep going.
295
00:32:29,394.7764935 --> 00:32:31,934.7764935
Nope, that's good because we're actually done with the oath.
296
00:32:31,974.7764935 --> 00:32:36,484.7764935
If you're going to become a bishop or a seminary rector or something like that, your oath is done.
297
00:32:36,484.7764935 --> 00:32:38,464.7764935
Those are the things that you've promised.
298
00:32:38,841.9209717 --> 00:32:40,671.9209717
but there's another category of stuff.
299
00:32:41,76.9209717 --> 00:32:43,206.9209717
People in the church say we'll get to that.
300
00:32:43,256.9209717 --> 00:32:52,973.6628282
Yeah, but i've interrupted you so many times So why don't you just we want to sum up? I want you to read that oath Okay, just we'll go straight through without me interrupting you.
301
00:32:52,973.6628282 --> 00:33:08,699.4894936
Okay So from the top with firm faith, I also believe everything contained in the word of god whether written or handed down in tradition Which the church either by a solemn judgment or by the ordinary and universal magisterium? sets forth to be believed as divinely revealed.
302
00:33:08,749.4894936 --> 00:33:09,759.4894936
So that's dogma.
303
00:33:09,829.4894936 --> 00:33:11,29.4894936
It's divinely revealed.
304
00:33:11,589.4894936 --> 00:33:13,569.4894936
We know that the church has defined that.
305
00:33:14,699.4894936 --> 00:33:21,829.4894936
I also firmly accept and hold each and everything definitely proposed by the church regarding teaching on faith and morals.
306
00:33:21,999.4894936 --> 00:33:23,659.4894936
So that's infallible doctrine.
307
00:33:23,989.4894936 --> 00:33:31,761.9509041
It's arrived at by reflection on dogmas and It is asserted to be infallible by the church.
308
00:33:32,741.9509041 --> 00:33:46,741.9509041
Moreover, I adhere with religious submission of will and intellect to the teachings which either the Roman Pontiff or the College of Bishops enunciate when they exercise their authentic magisterium, even if they do not intend to proclaim these teachings by a definite act.
309
00:33:47,61.9519041 --> 00:33:57,882.1978961
And so those are teachings sometimes on, issues that are at, are under dispute, but I submit to the competent authority.
310
00:34:00,542.1978961 --> 00:34:02,309.6322109
Take us into the next, Roman numeral.
311
00:34:02,359.6322109 --> 00:34:02,609.6322109
Yeah.
312
00:34:02,839.6322109 --> 00:34:14,229.6312109
So this actually, even though all of those categories are much more important, this is probably where the rubber hits the road for a lot of people, especially in our media saturated world.
313
00:34:14,534.8120994 --> 00:34:23,115.4617129
this is, stuff my priest said, or stuff that the bishop said, or stuff that the pope said on an airplane, or that article that I read.
314
00:34:23,327.4048803 --> 00:34:24,227.4048803
this is opinion.
315
00:34:24,562.4048803 --> 00:34:34,272.4048803
Uh, this is opinion on theology or morals or ethics or prudential judgments on how to live out the teachings of the church.
316
00:34:34,622.4048803 --> 00:34:46,12.4048803
Before you get there, isn't there something between those? And that is, things that are worthy of belief? Right, so what I'm thinking of is things like, that we get a lot of questions about.
317
00:34:46,672.4048803 --> 00:34:47,152.4048803
So...
318
00:34:47,582.4048803 --> 00:35:07,502.9451431
If I become Catholic, do I have to believe that the Virgin of Mary appeared at Fatima? Or, do I have to believe that she appeared to Juan Diego, Right? I mean, those are, there's certain kinds of things That are recommended for belief, but not required, right? Yeah, thank you for introducing that because that is, that does precede what I was going to talk about.
319
00:35:07,552.9461431 --> 00:35:09,502.9461431
And so, this isn't in the oath either.
320
00:35:09,502.9461431 --> 00:35:12,902.9461431
This isn't something that anybody would be required by the church to believe.
321
00:35:13,92.9461431 --> 00:35:19,822.9461431
But this is something that the competent authorities in the church have looked at and have said there's nothing contrary to dogma or doctrine here.
322
00:35:20,82.4627528 --> 00:35:22,122.4627528
this seems legit.
323
00:35:22,142.4627528 --> 00:35:23,512.4627528
It seems like there's nothing...
324
00:35:23,947.4627528 --> 00:35:25,897.4627528
Problematic or dangerous here.
325
00:35:26,407.4627528 --> 00:35:37,923.6459802
Uh, you're not required to believe it, but we neither do we forbid you from believing it? so that that would be things like apparitions or miracles Or certain pious opinions.
326
00:35:37,923.6459802 --> 00:35:47,858.6469802
So let's give a couple practical examples saints Okay, so when you like you have a you have a daughter named lucy named after saint lucy Right? Yep.
327
00:35:48,158.6469802 --> 00:35:48,988.6469802
And so St.
328
00:35:48,988.6469802 --> 00:35:58,475.5220601
Lucy is a little bit of a, little bit of a mysterious figure in the early church, right? In the sense that, you know, there's, there's attribution to her, but we don't know that much about her from a historical record.
329
00:35:58,775.5220601 --> 00:36:01,477.6573779
And yet the church says, well, Um, there was St.
330
00:36:01,477.6573779 --> 00:36:06,351.6920238
Lucie, and, we are recommended to believe in the stories about St.
331
00:36:06,351.6920238 --> 00:36:06,671.6920238
Lucie.
332
00:36:06,681.6920238 --> 00:36:12,531.6920238
So there's actually two categories at play here, because a canonization is an infallible declaration.
333
00:36:12,531.6920238 --> 00:36:15,161.6920238
So if the church tells me that this person is a saint...
334
00:36:15,506.6920238 --> 00:36:32,36.9223079
That I do need to submit to and believe that I need to believe all the stories but all of the stories not necessarily that That's where we come to the the prudential judgments of the the church authorities or of historians or what have you and so Yeah is st.
335
00:36:32,36.9223079 --> 00:36:32,851.8223079
Lucia st.
336
00:36:33,1.9223079 --> 00:36:33,901.9223079
Yes, she is the church.
337
00:36:33,901.9223079 --> 00:36:34,491.9223079
And that's infallible.
338
00:36:34,491.9223079 --> 00:36:36,331.9223079
The church asserts that infallibly.
339
00:36:36,331.9223079 --> 00:36:38,501.9223079
But all of the stories attributed to her.
340
00:36:38,511.9223079 --> 00:36:45,151.9223079
Are all of the details about her martyrdom or about, there are, there are legends that I love about, uh, apparitions of St.
341
00:36:45,151.9223079 --> 00:36:45,611.9223079
Lucie.
342
00:36:45,661.9213079 --> 00:36:45,911.9223079
Oh yeah.
343
00:36:46,121.9223079 --> 00:36:47,991.9223079
Does the church require me to believe those? No.
344
00:36:48,71.9213079 --> 00:36:48,341.9213079
Okay.
345
00:36:48,431.9223079 --> 00:36:49,471.9213079
It doesn't require me to believe those.
346
00:36:49,481.9213079 --> 00:37:32,317.8691193
Okay, secondly, Marian apparitions because this is a huge deal for for protestants who want to convert to catholicism Do I really need to believe that the virgin mary appeared at such and such a time in such and such a place And I think I thought one time I know I taught a lane class about this, but I don't uh, Lakeshore academy of evangelization That cory and I both work at but uh, I don't I think we did a podcast episode about this way back whenever yeah, we have talked about it before but but there's this whole thing about marian apparitions and that all of them are sort of recommended for belief, but not required belief, right? And this gets into a another way of articulating this that's sort of parallel to the structure we've been talking about.
347
00:37:32,347.8691193 --> 00:37:37,441.3056592
And that's if something is, part of public revelation or private revelation.
348
00:37:37,471.3056592 --> 00:37:37,801.3056592
Yes.
349
00:37:37,871.3056592 --> 00:37:41,741.3066592
And so public revelation would fit into that dogma category.
350
00:37:41,741.3066592 --> 00:37:45,322.0089227
So this is the, Sacred scriptures and the sacred tradition.
351
00:37:45,322.0089227 --> 00:37:48,42.0089227
This is something that's dogmatic and required to be believed.
352
00:37:48,72.0089227 --> 00:37:49,412.0089227
That's public revelation.
353
00:37:49,412.0089227 --> 00:38:12,241.1629898
That's for everybody private revelation is something that is not required for belief that god may have legitimately revealed it to you like The virgin mary may have appeared to you Um, and there are cases in which the church has ruled that it's very likely that she did Um, there are the famous ones like fatima or lords by the way for those of you who haven't listened to that Previous episode or taking that class.
354
00:38:12,731.1629898 --> 00:38:15,841.1629898
I think we went through and there's there's only like 11.
355
00:38:16,31.1629898 --> 00:38:20,81.1629898
There aren't many No, yeah, like people think that the catholic church is full of all these things.
356
00:38:20,81.1629898 --> 00:38:32,859.2436925
There's only like 10 or 11 marion apparitions in 2000 years that the church says this is worthy or highly recommended and that's because the the church authorities have Investigated they've gone through the evidence.
357
00:38:32,869.2436925 --> 00:38:44,539.2436925
They've said we think this looks legit You are welcome to believe that this is legit But we cannot and will not require you to assent to this because it's not part of public revelation.
358
00:38:44,539.2436925 --> 00:38:45,269.2436925
It's not dogmatic.
359
00:38:45,289.2436925 --> 00:38:48,689.2436925
It's not dogmatic, it's not doctrinal, and it's not required for salvation.
360
00:38:48,719.2436925 --> 00:38:48,969.2436925
Right.
361
00:38:49,739.2436925 --> 00:38:50,539.2426925
Okay, keep going.
362
00:38:50,799.2436925 --> 00:38:56,11.0225995
Yeah, so, so there's that category that would fall under the ones that are officially enunciated.
363
00:38:56,281.0235995 --> 00:39:12,736.0107622
In that in that oath, and then we get to the one that I was going into about opinion, the thing your priest said, the thing your bishop said, professor Peabody or Father Martinez or Bishop McButterpants, the Pope talking when he's, exhausted after three days in outer Mongolia or whatever.
364
00:39:12,746.0107622 --> 00:39:15,696.0107622
Pope's on an airplane and he starts going on about plastic.
365
00:39:15,716.0107622 --> 00:39:18,706.0107622
Okay, I'm gonna put it on the table because there's a lot of people.
366
00:39:18,936.0107622 --> 00:39:29,696.0107622
I think that most of our listeners, if they are considering Catholicism or not Catholics, we, our audience skews to people who are more theologically conservative.
367
00:39:29,846.0107622 --> 00:39:32,676.0107622
But not necessarily politically conservative.
368
00:39:32,886.0107622 --> 00:39:44,536.0107622
Not necessarily, but I'm just saying theologically that's, and I don't think that we necessarily have a lot of people who are like radical progressives who disagree with the teachings of the church that are like, you know, listening to this podcast.
369
00:39:44,836.0107622 --> 00:39:47,836.0107622
So what I'm going to say is that I think I know from a lot of you.
370
00:39:48,211.0107622 --> 00:40:00,451.0107622
That you get concerned because you go, I read in a news article that Pope Francis was on an airplane and he was on the way, you know, home from wherever on the airplane.
371
00:40:00,471.0107622 --> 00:40:05,271.0117622
And he said, X, Y, Z, and, you know, and I know I'm being.
372
00:40:05,331.0107622 --> 00:40:13,221.0107622
Probably a little bit facetious here, um, but it's like, you know, Pope Francis is against plastic straws because they'll kill the sea turtles.
373
00:40:13,731.0107622 --> 00:40:27,741.0107622
And if I become Catholic, do I have to believe every time that Pope Francis goes on about the plastic straws, am I sort of required as a Catholic to, to make that an article of faith? What say you Corey? Well, the short and simple answer is no.
374
00:40:28,26.0107622 --> 00:40:45,456.0107622
Um, you are not required and I know I'm being kind of facetious, but well, well, and the facetiousness I, I, I know is yeah, relevant to the situation, but this, this would be just as relevant if it was however many years ago, 30 years ago, and this was John Paul the second saying something that you didn't agree with.
375
00:40:45,476.0097622 --> 00:40:58,6.0107622
So if you, for those of you who've ever watched HBO series, the young Pope, if the next Pope is pious the 13th and he's some uber conservative and he starts going on about, I don't know, whatever.
376
00:40:58,86.0107622 --> 00:40:58,376.0107622
Hmm.
377
00:40:58,531.0107622 --> 00:41:14,891.0097622
And it's super conservative stuff, right? I mean, I guess it comes down to what are, if the Pope gases on and gives opinions, how, how obligated are we to believe in that? So if this is a matter of prudential judgment, so this is taking the teachings of the church.
378
00:41:14,941.0097622 --> 00:41:19,11.0107622
So, I mean, let's go with plastic straws because that was the one you brought up.
379
00:41:19,327.1892841 --> 00:41:38,603.0747616
based on, Dogma and doctrine, we know that God created the universe, God wants us to be good stewards of creation, we ought to, treat creation with respect, and part of that is treating it in a way that doesn't harm our neighbor or harms the environment in a way that isn't helpful.
380
00:41:38,894.8518158 --> 00:41:48,854.8518158
I'm not articulating it terribly clearly, but like we, we know those things and those, those, those things are, those things have like, like when we go back to the last episode about knowledge, those things are things that we can say.
381
00:41:49,114.8518158 --> 00:41:51,792.2264024
But then you, then you make an implication from that.
382
00:41:51,802.2264024 --> 00:41:55,201.8510224
Therefore, I recommend that the government enact.
383
00:41:55,216.8520224 --> 00:41:57,366.8520224
a policy of having only paper straws.
384
00:41:57,849.3398983 --> 00:42:05,927.7703064
that is, I know we're being kind of a little bit silly here, but what that is, is now traipsing into prudential judgments.
385
00:42:06,217.7703064 --> 00:42:14,413.2408593
And so that is making proposals or reasoning to conclusions based on the data in a non authoritative way.
386
00:42:14,563.2408593 --> 00:42:15,953.2408593
And that doesn't mean it's wrong.
387
00:42:15,963.2408593 --> 00:42:17,213.2408593
Like maybe the Pope is right.
388
00:42:17,588.2408593 --> 00:42:20,348.2408593
I don't actually know if the Pope has said plastic straw should be banned.
389
00:42:20,348.2408593 --> 00:42:22,468.2408593
I know, I'm being, I'm being intentionally facetious.
390
00:42:22,468.2408593 --> 00:42:24,688.2408593
But if Pope Francis did say that, maybe he's right.
391
00:42:24,938.2408593 --> 00:42:27,488.2398593
I'm not arguing that he, I'm not arguing that he isn't right.
392
00:42:27,738.2408593 --> 00:42:31,478.2408593
But I am arguing that you wouldn't be required to believe that.
393
00:42:31,478.2408593 --> 00:42:34,38.2408593
But as a matter of conscience, I can listen to him.
394
00:42:34,38.2408593 --> 00:42:41,728.2408593
And I do want to say this, because I told you before we started this recorder, I had seen a quote the other day from Aquinas, but I didn't save it.
395
00:42:42,568.2408593 --> 00:42:46,188.2408593
But Aquinas was talking about the respect and obedience that we owe the Pope.
396
00:42:47,168.2408593 --> 00:42:54,939.2408593
And for those of you who say, wow, you know, I don't like Pope Francis, or if the next Pope is super conservative, I don't like, you know, what his opinions mm-hmm.
397
00:42:55,18.2408593 --> 00:42:56,48.2408593
about, you know, this and that.
398
00:42:57,208.2408593 --> 00:43:03,358.2408593
You know, Aquinas says, look, basically it makes a distinction that I think a lot of us can understand the distinction between the office and the man.
399
00:43:03,628.2408593 --> 00:43:03,718.2408593
Mm-hmm.
400
00:43:03,958.2408593 --> 00:43:04,258.2408593
right.
401
00:43:04,608.8081739 --> 00:43:10,180.8481564
it's fair to say Thomas Aquinas says the, the man can be flawed.
402
00:43:10,708.3403114 --> 00:43:16,518.3403114
So we can go back in history and say, Hey, during the Renaissance, the Borgia popes were out of control or whatever.
403
00:43:17,28.3403114 --> 00:43:25,461.1911563
And you can say that there's a difference between the man and the man may make as a man, he may make.
404
00:43:25,961.1921563 --> 00:43:55,366.1921563
judgments and have failures and have foibles and frailties and and he comes out of a context, you know, Pope Francis comes from South America and he has a different perspective than A pope from another country or background or whatever, right? That's the man but we owe respect to the office And that's why I will never, have never, will never criticize in any public way on this podcast, on social media, in anything that I do, the Holy Father.
405
00:43:56,125.3523552 --> 00:43:59,835.3533552
I consider the Holy Father, well, I mean, He is the Holy Father.
406
00:43:59,835.3533552 --> 00:44:03,590.2533552
So, in the same way that I owe respect to my earthly Father.
407
00:44:03,817.1147194 --> 00:44:11,517.1147194
so you have the sons of Noah, and after the flood and all that, Noah gets drunk and he's laying, I don't know, naked in a tent, drunk, which is kind of weird.
408
00:44:11,807.1137194 --> 00:44:15,847.1137194
But anyway, one of his sons kind of laughs at him and goes, look dad, he's drunk and naked, you know.
409
00:44:15,847.1137194 --> 00:44:20,293.417368
And then the other sons come in backwards and like lay a, blanket over him or something like that.
410
00:44:20,513.417368 --> 00:44:23,863.418368
Because they show respect of their father even when he...
411
00:44:24,433.418368 --> 00:44:25,563.418368
Yeah, stumbles.
412
00:44:26,183.418368 --> 00:44:57,154.214378
And so again, Thomas Aquinas says we owe respect to the Holy Father and and I should listen, you know, to the pious opinion of the Holy Father, but there's a huge Difference between that and saying the things I am dogmatically required to believe as a Catholic, let me throw out an example for a different Pope earlier in history, just to kind of leave behind some of the baggage of current events that illustrates the fact that there's the Pope isn't always speaking on the same level of authority.
413
00:44:57,894.214378 --> 00:44:58,809.114378
And so, um.
414
00:44:58,809.314378 --> 00:45:01,851.7079594
Pius XII, Pope in the middle of the century.
415
00:45:01,851.7079594 --> 00:45:03,341.7079594
He was Pope during World War II.
416
00:45:03,371.7079594 --> 00:45:05,281.7079594
He survived into the 50s.
417
00:45:05,818.4835872 --> 00:45:22,689.1858507
there are a lot of people who have very strenuous disagreements with the prudential judgments that Pius XII made during the Second World War about what he did and didn't do to try and, negotiate or not negotiate with the Nazis or what he did or didn't do, to protect the Jews in Italy.
418
00:45:22,729.1858507 --> 00:45:23,499.1858507
Like, there's, there's...
419
00:45:23,509.1858507 --> 00:45:26,189.1858507
Or whether or not he cooperated.
420
00:45:26,389.1858507 --> 00:45:31,294.4175612
With the von Stauffenberg plot to assassinate Hitler with, the Dietrich Bonhoeffer.
421
00:45:31,564.4175612 --> 00:45:33,94.431847
So there were, like, just to acknowledge...
422
00:45:33,94.431847 --> 00:45:35,734.4175612
And if you think just war theory is bunk, then that would be bad.
423
00:45:35,734.4175612 --> 00:45:36,14.4175612
Right.
424
00:45:36,14.4175612 --> 00:45:42,531.912569
But what I'm just saying is, it was a very complicated situation and, you know, there were Nazi panzer tanks in St.
425
00:45:42,531.912569 --> 00:45:43,301.912569
Peter's Square.
426
00:45:43,591.912569 --> 00:45:47,621.912569
And the Pope had to make a lot of prudential judgments and he made a lot of calls.
427
00:45:47,881.912569 --> 00:45:50,311.912569
And some of his calls may have been right and some of his calls may have been wrong.
428
00:45:50,311.912569 --> 00:45:50,341.912569
Right.
429
00:45:50,521.912569 --> 00:45:52,351.912569
And so those are prudential judgments.
430
00:45:52,351.912569 --> 00:46:02,397.4854267
That's kind of at the lowest level of the, the Pope speaking with authority in 1950 Pope Pius the 12th defined the dogma of the assumption of our lady into heaven.
431
00:46:02,967.4854267 --> 00:46:06,967.4844267
That is the absolute highest level of authority that a Pope can speak with.
432
00:46:07,187.4844267 --> 00:46:15,317.4854267
It's what we call an ex cathedra statement, which simply means he's speaking as the Bishop from his chair, the cathedra, the Bishop of Rome, who has.
433
00:46:15,622.4854267 --> 00:46:21,172.4854267
The authority to dogmatically define something saying that this is divinely revealed.
434
00:46:21,192.4854267 --> 00:46:31,933.9042173
So you're saying that the same Pope who may have made prudential, judgments, which calls that may have been right, may have been wrong in a very complex, fluid, hysterical situation.
435
00:46:31,963.9032173 --> 00:46:32,203.9032173
Right.
436
00:46:32,263.9042173 --> 00:46:33,133.9042173
Also...
437
00:46:33,498.9042173 --> 00:46:55,8.9042173
Was able to define dogmatic things and by the way for those who are listening who go man The Pope can just make stuff up ex cathedra How many times in 2, 000 years has the spoke Pope spoken ex cathedra and defined something infallibly twice twice? And that doesn't mean that's the only time that has has exercised infallibility No, but but times in history The Pope has just sat in the chair of st.
438
00:46:55,8.9042173 --> 00:47:12,684.3519484
Peter and said I just declared this so for those People who are concerned man, you know, if you become catholic, you have to believe the pope is just going to mix stuff up all the time doesn't happen all the time, because Even in that ex cathedra way of speaking, the Pope's role is to defend the dogma that has been given to the church.
439
00:47:12,954.3519484 --> 00:47:25,40.3001861
I think we're going to have to have another episode where we talk about the role of the papacy in this because, I personally am of the opinion that the Pope's infallible teaching magisterial role is largely defensive.
440
00:47:26,55.3001861 --> 00:47:28,885.2001861
And I think we have talked about that a bit I want to explore that a little bit.
441
00:47:28,885.3001861 --> 00:47:30,305.3001861
Because I think it's largely defensive.
442
00:47:30,305.3001861 --> 00:47:34,285.3001861
In other words, I don't think that the role of the Pope is to make things up.
443
00:47:34,485.3001861 --> 00:47:36,115.3001861
I think it's to defend the Apostle.
444
00:47:36,115.3001861 --> 00:47:37,825.3001861
Well, that's not even just what you think.
445
00:47:37,825.3001861 --> 00:47:38,565.3001861
I'm pretty sure that's...
446
00:47:38,565.4001861 --> 00:47:39,465.3001861
That's Vatican I.
447
00:47:39,465.3001861 --> 00:47:39,885.3001861
That's just true.
448
00:47:39,885.4001861 --> 00:47:42,515.3011861
But I think we should explore that.
449
00:47:42,515.3011861 --> 00:47:44,275.3001861
Because I think people think, well, the Pope...
450
00:47:45,15.3001861 --> 00:47:46,125.3001861
Can just make things up.
451
00:47:46,135.3001861 --> 00:47:56,835.3001861
And I think there are, frankly, I think there are progressive Catholics who hope that Pope Francis will just declare some stuff contrary, like, you know, to the last 2, 000 years.
452
00:47:57,5.3001861 --> 00:47:57,575.2991861
Can't do it.
453
00:47:57,825.2991861 --> 00:48:00,495.3001861
It's largely preserving and defending.
454
00:48:01,200.3001861 --> 00:48:01,820.3001861
Uh, the faith.
455
00:48:01,910.3001861 --> 00:48:02,330.3001861
Yeah, right.
456
00:48:02,360.3001861 --> 00:48:02,670.3001861
Absolutely.
457
00:48:02,710.3001861 --> 00:48:02,990.3001861
Wow.
458
00:48:02,990.3001861 --> 00:48:14,200.3001861
This well, this was this is super fascinating I'm sure that there are people who are out there that like we've only scratched the surface and maybe only prompted further questions But the episode is getting a little bit long So, um, we're gonna stop here.
459
00:48:14,530.3001861 --> 00:48:23,303.1386151
Please write us love your emails and we a lot, you know often just choose the topics of episodes based on your emails.
460
00:48:23,513.1386151 --> 00:48:28,853.1386151
So if there's questions you have, things you want us to talk about, or just feedbacks and comments, please send them to us.
461
00:48:29,133.1386151 --> 00:48:30,483.1386151
You can send them to me at gregatconsideringcatholicism.
462
00:48:31,943.1376151 --> 00:48:36,133.1386151
com or just consideringcatholicism at gmail.
463
00:48:36,133.1386151 --> 00:48:38,118.1386151
com both of those will get to us.
464
00:48:38,398.1386151 --> 00:48:44,368.1386151
If you got things you want to send them on, I'll pass them on to Corey, pass them on to Ed, pass them on to anybody, but please give us feedback.
465
00:48:44,528.1386151 --> 00:48:46,618.1386151
And by the way, please support the podcast.
466
00:48:46,653.8480104 --> 00:48:50,753.8480104
we have no support from any church or diocese organization.
467
00:48:51,73.8480104 --> 00:49:01,564.0754419
We are a pretty much a, uh, a pretty small operation here, and we could use your support because we have a lot of ambitions for expanding this ministry and doing, um, more interesting things.
468
00:49:01,584.0754419 --> 00:49:12,747.6338294
So, please, uh, you can go to, uh, Our website, you can look in the, podcast description, whether you're on Spotify or Apple podcast or whatever, and just click there and it'll take you to a support page.
469
00:49:12,747.6338294 --> 00:49:14,27.6338294
So thank you very much.
470
00:49:14,57.6328294 --> 00:49:15,87.6338294
And thank you, Corey.
471
00:49:15,526.9115968 --> 00:49:17,146.9105968
it is now dark out here.
472
00:49:17,505.8311006 --> 00:49:18,765.8311006
It's pretty much pitch black.
473
00:49:18,795.8311006 --> 00:49:18,885.8311006
Yeah.
474
00:49:19,275.8311006 --> 00:49:21,973.2009816
I'm pretty sure that, I want to believe.
475
00:49:22,493.2009816 --> 00:49:29,63.2009816
I want to that Sasquatch is out here, but I just can't quite convince myself.
476
00:49:29,93.2009816 --> 00:49:30,863.1999816
And the church does not require you to believe that.
477
00:49:31,183.1999816 --> 00:49:31,443.1999816
That's right.
478
00:49:31,543.1999816 --> 00:49:31,763.1999816
Okay.
479
00:49:32,33.1999816 --> 00:49:34,953.2009816
Even if the Pope were to say that he thought Sasquatch was out there.
480
00:49:35,323.2009816 --> 00:49:35,773.2009816
That's right.
481
00:49:36,103.2009816 --> 00:49:36,313.2009816
All right.
482
00:49:36,313.2009816 --> 00:49:36,733.2009816
Thanks a lot Cory.
483
00:49:36,983.2009816 --> 00:49:37,443.2009816
Thank you.
484
00:49:39,469.2669 --> 00:49:40,549.2669
Thank you for listening.
485
00:49:41,119.2669 --> 00:49:52,169.2669
My name is Greg Smith, and if you've enjoyed this podcast, would you please hit the like and subscribe buttons wherever you get your podcasts, and please share it with others.
486
00:49:52,929.2669 --> 00:50:03,269.2669
And if you're curious about the Catholic worldview and faith, the church and its saints, or Catholic history, culture, and art, then visit consideringcatholicism.
487
00:50:03,299.2669 --> 00:50:06,329.2669
com and email me to let me know what you think.
488
00:50:06,919.2659 --> 00:50:09,309.2669
Greg at consideringcatholicism.
