Twenty Centuries. Twenty-Four Timezones. Two Hemispheres. One Church.

Considering Catholicism

Join me on Patreon!

This show is 100% listener-supported. My patrons keep the lights on and let me spend more time researching and recording so these episodes keep coming. If this show has helped you, would you consider joining them? For as little as $5 a month you get:

  • Albums: 400+ episodes in topical playlists
  • Questions/Coffee: weekly videos
  • Deep Dive Courses
  • Livestreams with Greg
  • Previews of Greg's upcoming History of Christendom Podcast

Just head to patreon.com/consideringcatholicism.



Reviews

Discovering Truth
Greg breaks down Scripture in " pockets" that are cohesive and digestible. This series is educational, spiritual, truthful, and factual. Greg has a gift for delivering information in a story like way that captivates interest and makes you want to learn more!
Depth and Beauty of Faith
I really enjoy how this podcast goes into the depth and beauty of the Catholic faith. Greg does a great job of breaking down Catholic concepts and traditions into fun and manageable episodes of understanding.
Seeking Truth
A wonderful introduction podcast for anyone who seeks to learn more about the Catholic faith. As a Protestant, this podcast has helps me wrestle through issues and gives me a fuller perspective of my Christian faith.
Great podcast
Very interesting and informative I look forward to hearing more!!!
The best way to discover Catholicism.
It's the best. Going through OCIA after 18 years with the Catholic Church. Trying to discover better understanding of what exactly Catholics believe and what I've missed in thst time.
Something Special
Extemporaneous podcasts have their place, but Greg’s preparation for each episode is exceptional. It’s clear he does it out of a profound respect for his listener and for the faith. As a result, there are many excerpts and full episodes worth listening to again and again. The compendium being built here is a gift to converts, reverts, and all seeking truth.
The best!
Considering Catholicism has been hugely formative for me on my road to Rome. Greg brings such depth of knowledge, weaving history and theology into every conversation. He engages Protestant perspectives with genuine respect, yet also speaks with clarity and conviction about where he sees them going astray. What sets this podcast apart from others is Greg’s background as a former Protestant pastor. Because he knows the standard Protestant arguments inside and out, he can address them with a dept
Great show
Really appreciate this podcast. Keep up the great work! I’ve already passed an episode along to a good Protestant friend. May God bless you ✝️
Finally “my favorite podcast”
I have been searching for a podcast for years to really catch my attention. There are many that cover topics. I’m interested in, but none of them were really staying on my radar week after week until I found “Considering Catholicism”. Most naturally episodes on faith topics are profound and resonating. What really hooked me was one specific episode. After being a working actor for a living 15 years in Hollywood and 15 years in New York and overseas I was completely blown away by the insight I fo
Fantastic podcast for new and perspective Catholics!
I am a fairly recent Catholic convert (2023), and I still have so many things to learn about the Catholic faith. This podcast has been invaluable. Mr. Smith and his guests provide a wealth of information in a measured, clear way. From the reality of Heaven to cultural matters, there is something for everyone here.
Charitable Truth
Considering Catholicism keeps the faith through, with, and in, the Love of God. This podcast is an excellent example of sharing charitably sharing the faith without watering it down. Greg’s humility and integrity are an inspiration for all those who seek to be loyal sons and daughters of Holy Mother Church… The latest episode that I just listened to (The Cost of Discipleship, Part 2 #356) was my favorite. The most recent episode I’ve listened to tends to be my favorite.
Fantastic podcast for new and perspective Catholics!
I am a fairly recent Catholic convert (2023), and I still have so many things to learn about the Catholic faith. This podcast has been invaluable. Mr. Smith and his guests provide a wealth of information in a measured, clear way. From the reality of Heaven to cultural matters, there is something for everyone here.
My Favorite Catholic Podcast!
I could listen to this podcast forever! I recently was confirmed into the Catholic Church Easter 2025, and I have gained a deeper understanding of the faith from listening to Considering Catholicism in addition to OCIA classes. I like how eloquently information is conveyed, and how logical and factual it is. I appreciate the deep dives into everything and how compehensive the episodes are. Great production quality in addition to the excellent content!
I WAS A PASTOR, NOW I’M CATHOLIC!
My whole life I was Protestant, and for nearly a decade I was a Pastor, but that all changed when I began to consider Catholicism. I mean that in both ways, I began to consider Catholicism, and Considering Catholicism was one of the first podcasts I started listening to that helped answer my curious questions. This podcast was very meaningful to my journey. Greg Smith already knew where my Protestant brain was at and was able to predict my questions and objections, answering them in ways that ma
You match my thoughts.
You match my thoughts exactly yet I am so unable to express correctly. This latest talented podcast about electing a certain kind of Pope struck me very hard and was entirely as I would wish to identify the kind of Pope we need in the Church and in the world! Thank you…100%.
The learning never ends
As someone with a Protestant background who walked away from faith altogether, I have found that perhaps what I was missing was Catholicism. I am still on a journey. Greg clearly and with great intellectual honesty answered SO many of my questions. He teaches from the perspective of a former Protestant, so he addresses all the things I was taught in that world. If you have lots of honest questions, you will find many satisfying answers here.
So helpful, thank you! 👏👏
I started exploring Catholicism after a heart transformation in my mid-30s, and this podcast has been an absolute blessing in my life! I’m so grateful for your hard work in producing this show. The Holy Spirit is working through you in such a beautiful way to explain Catholicism in a way that anyone can understand, and it’s changing my life. Keep up the great work, Greg!!
BRAVO! Pure ear candy!
What a great teacher. Plainly stating and backing up with personal stories from his protestant years.
Incredibly helpful in clearing Reformed obstacles to Catholicism!
Greg has a fantastic podcast here with a tenor and rapport that makes you want to listen. I feel like Ed is spot on in representing some of my hesitations as I considered Catholicism, and have since started RCIA at a local FSSP parish. I hope Greg and Cory talk about A Canticle For Leibowitz in the book club soon!
Informative, inspiring and entertaining
As a lapsed atheist in search of purpose and meaning this podcast has proved invaluable. In fact it is a huge factor in me starting RCIA back in September 2023. Greg has a real gift for unpacking information and making it understandable for a newbie like myself. In addition the conversations with Ed the protestant are just really entertaining. I couldn't recommend this podcast highly enough.
Considering Protestant
Found this podcast after searching “Catholic.” As a Methodist who is considering Catholicism I have enjoyed all the in depth explanations of Catholicism. You have debunked a lot of misbeliefs I had about the faith. Getting my toes wet and feel this tugging at my heart
Wonderfully Succinct
Greg does a phenomenal job of taking complex topics and breaking them down so they are not only easier to understand but also easier to share in conversation with others. As a cradle Catholic, this podcast has helped strengthen my faith, theology, and apologetics, all while keeping me chuckling frequently. Thank you, and keep up the great work!
My review
Top notch Catholic podcast - it was the first Catholic podcast I listened to as a Protestant skeptic of Rome, but have since then joined RCIA and will be welcomed into the Church this Easter.
A favorite podcast I look forward to listening with great enthusiasm!
Thank you Greg for your amazing and educational podcast! I am a recent revert to the Catholic faith after 7 years of wandering away adopting a hybrid of New Age spirituality and nondenominational Protestant ways of practicing the Christian faith. I discovered your podcast a few months ago and can’t get enough of it. It’s one of my favorite weekly intellectual and spiritual treats. I appreciate the clarity and charity you embody in educating the audience. With gratitude from a big fan! Keep
Great resource on the Catholic faith!
I love this podcast, my girlfriend and I listen to it all the time!
This podcast is a light in a lost and confused world
These guys are so helpful. They explain things in a way people can understand, my heart has truly been opened to the idea of Catholicism, I am currently fighting the social aspects of it but by this podcast and other sources I have had practically all of my reservations explained away. I would recommend this to anyone. Blessings 🙏🏻
Bringing me to God
This podcast, Greg Smith’s dedication, and simplistic yet intelligent and articulate way of describing things; has helped me so much in my journey with God. As an atheist to Catholic convert who’s just joined a church for the first time, thank you for educating and inspiring. ✝️
Invaluable resource
Thank you for this ministry. It is not only educational for me as a cradle Catholic, but an invaluable resource that I have recommended often. This podcast has not only equipped me with the information to explain my faith but also provides a practical aid to share with others who have questions or are curious about the Catholic Church. Always look forward to the next episode!
Appreciation From an Anglican
I was raised Catholic and left the faith over a decade ago. Last year I resumed going to church, this time an Episcopal one. I was still rather anti-Catholic until I found this podcast. It's very educational on Catholic theology and dispels a lot of Protestant slander about the Church. My theology has now shifted to be very Anglo Catholic. I'm very sympathetic to Roman Catholicism and now pray the Rosary and ask for Saint intercession. Greg is very smart and a wonderful speaker
Engaging and Educational
I’m in my 30s and I was convinced of the Catholic faith about 2.5 years ago. As early as I can remember, I was raised in a mainline evangelical Pentecostal/Charismatic church, and then as an adult I did a deep dive into theology and eventually joined a confessional Presbyterian church. Long story short, I learned about the traditional reformed view of baptism, that it does save but only the for the elect. This discovery eventually led me to hearing arguments from Catholic apologists, which immed
An amazing help with my walk with Jesus!
This podcast has been a great help as I try to walk closer with Jesus. I officially entered the Catholic Church this past Easter after a journey of many years. The discussions on this podcast were used by God to help me along. Thank you so much!
Protestant enjoying and learning
Growing up a Protestant, I have some misconceptions about Catholicism. This podcast has helped clarify aspects of Catholicism and made me want to learn more about my current denomination. I am currently questioning my denomination but never have I questioned my faith in Jesus as my savior.
Understanding the Catholic church
I’m a 23 year old girl raised in a Protestant reformed church but I befriended a girl who was Catholic and she had lots of questions for me regarding my church. As I was answering her questions I began to realize I didn’t actually know the answers, and a big questions that stuck with me was this: what did the church looked like from the death of Christ until now? Protestantism is roughly 500 years old, so does that mean no one has gone to heaven? As I dove into this question and others I had, I
Thank you!
This is helping me so much! I have been a Protestant my whole life and am curious about Catholicism and this podcast is helping answer a lot of my questions. Also a lot of misconceptions I've had have been straightened out. It's so refreshing!
Great Show
As a cradle Catholic, this podcast has opened my eyes. It is very useful to hear the faith described in such a informative way. Greg has a real talent for explaining big concepts in a way easily understood by regular people. A very big help formulating answers to Protestant objections, especially on a college campus.
Compelling
The more I listen to this show, the more I cannot stop listening. It is filling gaps in my Protestant upbringing that led me to leave the Christian faith completely for about 10 years. I am now on my way to becoming Catholic and feel so blessed to have found this podcast. Catholicism is truly good and beautiful. Thank you Greg and all other contributors to the podcast.
Helpful, Engaging, Insightful
Started this podcast as a companion to RCIA classes and so glad that I did! As a Christian who found my faith in college and married into a Catholic family, I would say my journey to Rome has also been a long one. Greg’s story is inspiring and he has a way of engaging the listener where you just can’t stop! My husband has even started listening and has learned things he wasn’t taught during his catchesis. Highly recommend!
Love Greg!
Greg’s background not only helps those coming from a Protestant denomination but lends so much depth to his discussions on Catholicism. My husband and I became hooked on this podcast several months ago and have been having such great daily discussions on the things we’ve heard and learned. We’re listening to new releases in real time and going back on our own to catch up on the older episodes we’ve missed.
wonderful podcast
I highly recommend this podcast for anyone struggling with their faith journey -- or even lack thereof. Greg's focus is based in part on his personal journey as a Protestant minister, ultimately embracing Catholicism about a decade ago, after years of searching for answers to his own questions. His passion, his ministry, is to help others who might harbor similar questions or intrigue about a faith tradition that had its origins in the Upper Room in Jerusalem not long after the ascension of Chri
Highly recommend
Love this podcast! Thankful for the time and efforts behind each episode. Thank you!!

Recent Episodes

Nov. 25, 2025

Further Up and Further In (#409)

[DONATE WITH PAYPAL] What if the Christianity you’ve always known is only the shallow end of a vast, ancient ocean? In this candid, burrito-fueled conversation (yes, really), Greg and Ed the Protestant unpack the longing that...

Listen to the Episode
Nov. 23, 2025

Divine Mysteries: Logos, Christ, Pantoccrator, Returning King (#408)

[DONATE WITH PAYPAL] In Part 3 of Divine Mysteries, Greg lets five explosive Scripture passages—John 1, Colossians 1, Philippians 2, Hebrews 1, and Revelation—paint the full portrait of the eternal Son, from Creator-Logos to ...

Listen to the Episode
Nov. 20, 2025

Our Lord Jesus Christ, King of the Universe (#407)

[DONATE WITH PAYPAL] As "Ordinary Time" comes to an end this Sunday (November 23), here's a classic episode from the CC vault: Greg and Cory unpacking what "feasts" or "feast days" are in the Catholic Church, the end of Ordin...

Listen to the Episode
Nov. 19, 2025

Divine Mysteries: The Incarnation (#406)

[DONATE WITH PAYPAL] The Athanasian Creed doesn’t stop at the Trinity. In its second half it lays down the Chalcedonian definition of the Incarnation—two natures, one Person—and declares it essential for salvation. Greg walks...

Listen to the Episode
Nov. 16, 2025

Divine Mysteries: The Trinity (#405)

[DONATE WITH PAYPAL] What makes Christianity unique? It’s the Trinity—Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, one God in three persons. In this episode, Greg dives into why the Trinity is the non-negotiable heart of the Christian faith...

Listen to the Episode
Nov. 12, 2025

Catholic Education Options for Parents (#404)

[DONATE WITH PAYPAL] Greg and Cory dive into the practical options for Catholic parents educating school-aged children. They emphasize parents as primary educators, supported by parish programs and schools. Discussions cover ...

Listen to the Episode
Nov. 9, 2025

Catholic Education: Goals and Challenges (#403)

[DONATE WITH PAYPAL] Greg and Cory explore the foundational principles of education and what sets Catholic education apart. They discuss how true Catholic formation goes beyond mere knowledge and skills to orient young lives ...

Listen to the Episode
Nov. 6, 2025

OCIA: The Four Marian Dogmas (#402)

[DONATE WITH PAYPAL] Why do Catholics make such a big deal about Mary? For many Protestants exploring Catholicism, the Blessed Virgin is the last hill to climb. In this episode, Greg dives into the four Marian dogmas—Mother o...

Listen to the Episode
Nov. 4, 2025

OCIA: The Communion of the Saints (#401)

[DONATE WITH PAYPAL] In this episode of OCIA: The Bridge to Rome , we unpack the communion of saints—the living, eternal family that unites the Church on earth with the triumphant saints in heaven. Drawing from the Apostles’ ...

Listen to the Episode
Nov. 2, 2025

400th Anniversary Episode: Big Plans for the Future! (#400)

[DONATE WITH PAYPAL] In this milestone 400th episode, Greg and Ed celebrate at the Secret Compound, munching on gas station pizza and sipping celebratory beverages. They reflect on the incredible journey of Considering Cathol...

Listen to the Episode
Oct. 30, 2025

Why Proving God Misses the Point: A Fresh Look at Belief (#399)

[DONATE WITH PAYPAL] Can you prove God exists like a math theorem? Greg shares his journey from a debate-obsessed college kid to a Catholic who sees belief differently. In this episode, he challenges the idea that faith is ab...

Listen to the Episode
Oct. 28, 2025

Catholic Social Teaching: Rorschach Test or Roadmap? (#398)

[DONATE WITH PAYPAL] Catholic Social Teaching, rooted in Pope Leo XIII’s 1891 encyclical Rerum Novarum , is meant to guide Catholics in building a just society, but today it’s often a battleground for political agendas. In th...

Listen to the Episode
Oct. 26, 2025

OCIA: Step Into Sacred Space – A Tour of the Catholic Church (#397)

[DONATE WITH PAYPAL] In this follow-up to episode #396 in the OCIA: The Bridge to Rome series, Greg takes listeners on a virtual tour of a Catholic church, revealing how its consecrated spaces—from the narthex’s sacred pause ...

Listen to the Episode
Oct. 23, 2025

OCIA: The Mass: A Portal to Eternal Worship (#396)

[DONATE WITH PAYPAL] In this episode of the "OCIA: The Bridge to Rome" series, Greg explores the Catholic Mass as the central act of worship, explaining its purposes, structure, and profound biblical roots. He contrasts it wi...

Listen to the Episode
Oct. 21, 2025

Natural Law: Why the Church Cares About Your Past Vows (#395)

[DONATE WITH PAYPAL] When a Protestant or non-Catholic wants to join the Catholic Church, they often hit a surprising snag: If they’re divorced and remarried, the Church requires an annulment for that first marriage—even if i...

Listen to the Episode
Oct. 19, 2025

OCIA: Scripture and Tradition (#394)

[DONATE WITH PAYPAL] "OCIA: The Bridge to Rome: Scripture, Tradition, and the Catholic Bible" explores how God’s revelation flows through Sacred Scripture and Tradition, guarded by the Magisterium. Greg shares his journey fro...

Listen to the Episode
Oct. 16, 2025

What's Up With Ed the Protestant? (#393)

ONATE WITH PAYPAL] Join Greg and Ed the Protestant at the secret compound in the Piney Woods for a heartfelt and candid conversation as Ed shares a long-awaited update on his journey toward Catholicism. With the 400th episode...

Listen to the Episode
Oct. 14, 2025

No Bad News = No Good News: The Cost of Soft-Pedaling Sin (#392)

[DONATE WITH PAYPAL] Greg and Ed the Protestant dive into a lively discussion about the fading concept of sin in contemporary Protestant and Evangelical churches. They explore how the gospel’s power hinges on the reality of b...

Listen to the Episode
Oct. 12, 2025

OCIA: The Creeds, a Summary of the Gospel (#391)

[DONATE WITH PAYPAL] This episode in the series "OCIA: The Bridge to Rome" dives into the Apostles’ and Nicene Creeds as vibrant summaries of the Gospel. Greg shares his journey from a deconstructed Evangelical hipster “fello...

Listen to the Episode
Oct. 9, 2025

The Holy Spirit Part 2: Catholic Mysticism and Miracles (#390)

[DONATE WITH PAYPAL] Greg delves deeper into the Catholic mystical tradition, defining mysticism as a profound union with God and tracing its history from early Church fathers to modern saints. Highlighting figures like St. H...

Listen to the Episode
Oct. 7, 2025

Holy Spirit, Part 1: Speaking in Tongues and Slain in the Spirit? A C…

[DONATE WITH PAYPAL] In this first part of a series on the Holy Spirit’s role in extraordinary experiences, host Greg Smith explains charismatic gifts like speaking in tongues, prophecy, words of knowledge, and healing, addre...

Listen to the Episode
Oct. 5, 2025

OCIA: The Holy Spirit and the Seven Sacraments (#388)

[DONATE WITH PAYPAL] Discover the Spirit’s role and how sacraments like Baptism and Eucharist use matter—water, bread, oil—to effect divine change, rooted in Scripture and the Catechism. Greg contrasts Catholic efficacious sa...

Listen to the Episode
Oct. 1, 2025

Noah's Ark to Peter's Boat: Typology in the Sistine Ceiling (#387)

[DONATE WITH PAYPAL] Building on his episode about Michelangelo's Creation of Adam (#385, "God's Finger"), Greg shifts focus to the nearby Deluge panel on the Sistine Chapel ceiling, where Noah's Ark resembles a Roman basilic...

Listen to the Episode
Sept. 29, 2025

OCIA: The Catholic Church (#386)

[DONATE WITH PAYPAL] Greg continues the series "OCIA: The Bridge to Rome" by exploring the Church as Christ’s living Body and instrument of grace. Discover its nature as the Body of Christ, People of God, and Temple of the Ho...

Listen to the Episode
Sept. 27, 2025

God's Finger: Are We Saved By Our Own Works? (#385)

[DONATE WITH PAYPAL] Dive into Michelangelo's iconic Creation of Adam fresco and uncover how it flips the secular view of religion as humanity's quest for the divine. Greg explores the Christian narrative of God reaching down...

Listen to the Episode